Experts discuss the ‘politics of food’ in South L.A.



imageThis week, the United States Department of Agriculture and Department of Health released new dietary guidelines. Updated every five years, the food pyramid taught in classrooms around the nation is a beacon of healthy food choices.

This year, the pyramid says Americans have been eating too much salt, so much so, in fact, that it urges them to cut their salt intake in half.

Despite the revamping of the food pyramid, despite the flashy graphics and colorful design that becomes more aesthetically pleasing twice a decade, Americans are getting fatter. Almost one third of adults in the United States are overweight or obese, compared to about 15 percent 30 years ago. Diabetes rates are skyrocketing.

The food pyramid is based on the assumption that good nutrition stems from individual behavior; individual behavior drives our consumption. People make choices, and making a healthy choice is a good decision. The question becomes, can everyone make that same healthy choice?

David Sloane, professor of Policy, Planning and Development at the University of Southern California, says we can’t. Sloane spoke Thursday in the Tudor Campus Center to a room full of University of Southern California students and faculty. He was one of four speakers during a lunch panel discussion on the “Politics of Food.”

Sloane, who has been studying food distribution for 11 years, says residents of South Los Angeles have far fewer choices than those in more affluent communities.

It is a crisis of equity.

Sloane’s research team did a series of comparisons between restaurants and grocery stores in West and South Los Angeles in 2001 and 2006, and is gearing up for another round this year.

Restaurants

Sloane’s team found that there was a discrepancy both in choice of restaurants and on the menus within the restaurants in South and West Los Angeles.

“West Los Angeles is one of those places where people have the ability to make those choices,” said Sloane. “It’s one of the richest food environments one could imagine in the United States. There are tons of fast food restaurants, but there are tons of fast food restaurants everywhere in the United States. The difference is, do you have a choice?”

Three quarters of the restaurants in South Los Angeles are fast food restaurants, compared to less than half of the restaurants in West Los Angeles.

“But restaurant distribution are just points on a map,” said Sloane. He also wanted to know about the options once inside the restaurant.

In 2001 and 2002, Sloane sent people into restaurants to answer a simple question of the menus. Not of people, just the menus. The surveyors noted the transparency of healthy alternatives.

The difference was statistically significant. In West Los Angeles, it was common; in South Los Angeles, it was practically nonexistent.

These choices, or lack thereof, make up the profile of the separate food systems. To create a comprehensive food profile of the two areas, the team factored in grocery stores, community gardens and alternative sources of food.

Sloane discovered that places with high minority or low-income populations have a very different profile than places with lots of money. Namely, they have far fewer choices.

“The simple statement that policy makers often make to those kinds of people, ‘Oh, just eat better, and you’ll be healthier,’ isn’t actually that easy to do,” said Sloane.

The impact is evident. South Los Angeles has both the poorest and most overweight people in the Southland. Over 30 percent of the population lives under the poverty line. Thirty-five percent of adults are overweight or obese.

Grocery Stores

imageGrocery stores between the two communities had a gap just as wide as restaurants.

“I’m an aficionado of Trader Joe’s,” said Sloane. “I can go to Washington and I can go to Trader Joes, I can go to Atlanta and go to Trader Joe’s, but I can’t go to Trader Joe’s in South Los Angeles.”

When looking at a map of grocery store locations in Los Angeles, the sparse distribution of stores in South Los Angeles might make one think that the community can’t support more. Sloane says that isn’t true.

Through tracking spending patters, Sloane found that tens of millions of dollars are exported annually to the ring of grocers around South Los Angeles, such as Culver City, Westchester and Downtown Los Angeles.

Not only does this mean money is leaving the already impoverished community, but it also indicates the grocers within South Los Angeles are not meeting the needs of the residents.

The team created a neighborhood food watch. Made up of community residents, the food watch group went to grocery stores with a checklist. They found a significant amount of grocery stores in South Los Angeles have expired food on the shelves. Sloane was surprised to learn that that there is no governmental body that regulates expired food in the US, with the exception of baby formula. Everything else is managed by private sector manufactures.

Steps Taken

The group came up with strategies to address problems at restaurants and stores.

Working with the community redevelopment agency and grocers, they began a campaign to get better food into South Los Angeles grocery stores about 10 years ago.

The group also developed incentives for grocers to move into South Los Angeles, including subsidies for opening stores in underserved neighborhoods.

Sloane says the initiatives have made a difference. “Is the food profile different today? Yes, it’s better than it was back then. It’s not better enough, there’s not enough choices, and there’s still big food deserts, places where it’s hard to make those choices.”

It was more difficult to think of solutions for restaurants. Because a large part of the problem were lack of choices within restaurants and a saturation of fast food, advocates pushed for a moratorium on fast food restaurants while the residents of South Los Angeles figured out how to improve the food system.

In the fall of 2008, the Los Angeles City Council passed the Interim Control Ordinance. The ordinance made a two-year ban on permits for stand-alone fast food restaurants.

When the ban ended last fall, residents came to the city council with a new solution: they wanted to manage the number of curb cuts.

All drive-thrus need to cut into the curb so cars can go in one side and come out the other. That means two new curb cuts per a fast food restaurant. By controlling the number of curb cuts, the community can control the number of new fast food restaurants.

The Planning Commission, the body that currently regulates the number of curb cuts, passed a piece of legislation giving the control of curb cuts to the communities in South Los Angeles.

Though it is small, it is enough to ensure South Angelenos can prevent fast food restaurants from clustering in one area.

What Next?

Sloane’s group hopes to create an economic food development food trust. Modeled after a program in Pennsylvania, the trust would have resources for people to start grocery stores in underserved communities that they would then pay back into the trust.

To address the lack of healthy options in restaurants, Sloane wants to create healthy food zones to complement the idea of curb cuts. The program would provide subsidize to healthy restaurants.

“We don’t just try to keep bad food out; we try to get good food into South Los Angeles,” said Sloane.

Photos courtesy of Creative Commons

Comments

  1. I would suggest for LA County to start working, in Willowbrook. In Willowbrook, there is only two SuperMarkets, and one restaurant. If LA City is not doing, the county should. Willowbrook is part of the county and they start working in building another SuperMarket and another sit-down restaurant, it would be a win-win situation, the residents of Willowbrook would have more option to buy food, and so the residents of the city of L.A. (Watts, Green Meadows). Willowbrook has many areas that are blight, yet nothing seems to be done.

  2. I think the findings of the wall art research show a sad fact of the world today – that fresh, healthy food is more expensive than mass-produced food filled with additives. Unfortunately for residents, this leaves them with little choice if they are below the poverty line, and businesses too – maybe they want to offer healthy food, but their customers can’t afford it?

  3. Over two hundred years have passed since its Independence, and Haiti remains trailing behind the developing world. Now that we have entered a new and strange phase in Haiti, perhaps the lowest ever, from sporadic kidnappings, murders, to a society of lawlessness, should we sit and wait for solutions from a dubious International Community? Or should we be seeking our own solutions to our existing problems? The country that used to be the model for freedom lovers now finds itself in a different kind of a struggle, a struggle where poverty, public safety, education and unemployment become the core enemy of its inhabitants. What should we do to eradicate Haiti’s rampant problems? Where should we begin? Or should we even bother? Others, including myself, would argue that, amongst other things, Haiti’s political party system is a menace to its political stability. Thus, we cannot turn our backs on Haiti. We must help control and reduce the problems of Haiti.
    kitchen remodelling
    kitchen remodel plans
    kitchen remodel contractor

  4. eligempondoni says:

    <a ><img>http://canadahomesecuritysystems.com/images/banner.png</img></a&gt;

    If you may be in the market for a security system for your property in Canada, it’s a very good idea to learn about the different solutions that are offered in the market place. With such a large number of home security services sold nowadays, you can personalize the best home security plan which is right for your house, household and daily activities.

    Our current economic dilemma has a lot of families anxious about the possible increase in break-ins throughout their neighborhoods as well as the safeness and security of their family members, residences and valuables. Lots of home owners are purchasing wireless and monitored security systems to meet their security needs.

    Home security systems in Toronto and elsewhere are common, prudent homeowners are lessening their odds of burglary and theft by having home alarm systems installed in their households. Home security systems may help protect houses by scaring off prospective burglars with deafening audible alarms, window decals and signs displayed in easily visible places such as front yards.

    Given that the technology used is wireless, installation can occur swiftly and easily. No longer is it necessary to put holes in walls to lay cables, installation can occur within a couple of hours. When you purchase 24/7 monitoring plan, you can feel comfortable knowing if your alarm is set off, police will be informed and dispatched to check on your house.

    You do not need to possess a telephone land line to reap the benefits of a wireless home alarm system. A cellular phone can be utilized by the monitoring company who keeps an eye on the status of your system. As soon as the security alarm is activated the standard course of action is that the monitoring specialist will first get hold of you or the contact of record to make sure a false alarm isn’t the cause. If they determine that it’s not a false alarm or they cannot speak to you, the alarm monitoring company will instantaneously notify local emergency authorities who will respond to the situation.

    A lot of security system dealerships will cover the cost of the hardware once you sign up for a monitoring program making the expense to start surprisingly low. A dependable home security company in Vancouver or anywhere can install your system in a matter of days and oftentimes, the following day if that is what you prefer.

    The most up-to-date security equipment incorporates window sensors, door sensors and motion detectors. The window and door sensing devices are activated whenever a window or door is opened, even by a tiny amount. The motion detectors can sense activity for up to 50 feet, therefore they are an excellent tool that will help protect indoor areas. They may also be set up to enable the activity of most pets without setting off the burglar alarm. Most standard systems include window and door sensors, motion detectors, an illuminated control panel, battery back-up power in the event electricity has gone out and some also provide a keychain remote that enables you to easily arm and deactivate the security alarm system at a distance.

    Homeowners choose to put in security systems for a number of reasons, primarily for their desire to feel safer and a lot more protected while at home or away. Many homeowners use their systems when they’re home and before retiring for the night and whenever they depart for work or going away on holiday.

    No matter what your reasons for installing a wireless home alarm system, there is no better time to benefit from the cost effective security packages available. Choose a reliable provider that has 24/7 monitoring capabilities and a professional and dedicated staff.

    Here are some important link that can help you to find-out free home security system and can help you to get low cost home security system:

    <a >Home security systems in Toronto</a>
    <a >Home security systems</a>
    <a >home security company in Vancouver</a>
    <a >home security systems</a>
    <a >ADT security</a>
    <a >home alarm systems in Calgary</a>

  5. Experts are discussing politic. Society has a large focus on politic. And everyone is aware of the basic theory that should result in politic. It requires eating less and exercising more; simple and to the point.
    kitchen remodel
    remodeling kitchen cabinets
    good contractor
    info kitchen
    about kitchen

Speak Your Mind

*